Activity of European Military-Instruction Missions in the Countries of South-Eastern Europe at the beginning of the XX century

Main Article Content

Abstract

This article studies one of the components of the history of modernization processes in the countries of South-Eastern Europe in the latter half of the 19th century – the early 20th century – military modernization.


The purpose of research is to analyze the role of foreign military assistance in formation of military forces of Romania, Serbia, Bulgaria, Montenegro, Albania and Greece. Separate directions of military assistance provided to the countries of South-Eastern Europe in the form of military missions, training of officers in Europe, arms export and other aspects are disclosed.


One of the markers of military development during the period in question was the military instructor activity of the developed European countries in the framework of military modernization of possible military allies in these countries.


The lower limit of research is the Bosnian crisis in 1908 caused by annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina by Austria-Hungary. The conflict was the reason of rapid militarization of the region. Military missions from the countries of Europe began their activity in Greece, Montenegro, Turkey. Thousands of officers from Balkan army studied in military establishments of Europe. The top limit of the research is the First world war І 1914-1918. The obvious success was attained with modernization of the armed forces of allies by military missions from Germany in Turkey and from France in Romania in that time.


The work deals with the process of military modernization, i.e. the activities of military instructor missions of the leading European countries during the interwar period. The time interval of the study ranges within 1908-1918. This was the period marked by modernization of new national armies in Eastern Europe. Military missions played an important role in this complex process.


The comparison of the results of transformations provides for better understanding of the regional specifics and concrete results of this form of military modernization of armed forces during the twenty-year interwar period.


The method for comparing variations of military modernization of armies of Oriental countries occurring at the turn of the 20th centuries and reorganization of military forces of the countries of South-Eastern Europe is used. This method instantiates results, consequences, failures and success of military modernization.


The research is relevant for studying modern processes of military modernization.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Fal’ko, S. (2021) “Activity of European Military-Instruction Missions in the Countries of South-Eastern Europe at the beginning of the XX century”, Problems of World History, (13), pp. 24–52. doi: 10.46869/2707-6776-2021-13-2.
Section
Articles
Author Biography

S.A. Fal’ko

Fal’ko Sergii – Ph.D. in History, Associate Professor, Associate Professor of the National Academy of the National Guard of Ukraine.

References

Kashirin, V.B. (2011). Vysshij i starshij komandnyj sostav armij stran Balkanskogo poluostrova v ocenkah i suzhdeniyah russkih voennyh specialistov v nachale XX veka [The highest and senior command personnel of the armies of the countries of the Balkan Peninsula in the assessments and judgments of Russian military specialists at the beginning of the 20th century]. A man in the Balkans through the eyes of Russians: a collection of articles [Chelovek na Balkanah glazami russkih: sbornik statej] (pp. 169-189). SPb.: Aletejya. [In Russian].

Istoriya Balkan. Na perelome epoh (1878-1914 gg.), (2017). [History of the Balkans. At the turn of the eras (1878-1914)]. Moskva: Institut slavyanovedeniya RAN. [In Russian].

Fal’ko, S.A. (2018). Z istoriyi voyennoyi modernizatsiyi na Skhodi v druhiy polovyni XIX st.: diyal’nist’ instruktors’kykh misiy viys’kovoho ministerstva Rosiys’koyi imperiyi v Aziyi [From the history of military modernization in the East in the second half of the XIX century: the activities of instructor missions of the Ministry of War of the Russian Empire in Asia]. Hileya: naukovyy visnyk. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats’ [Gileya: scientific bulletin. Collection of scientific works], 130, 3, pp. 141-151. [In Ukrainian].

Fal’ko, S.A. (2020). Inozemna viys’kova dopomoha v modernizatsiyi zbroynykh syl derzhav Pivdenno-skhidnoyi Yevropy u druhiy polovyni XIX – pochatku XX st.: porivnyal’nyy aspekt [Foreign military assistance in the modernization of the armed forces of South-Eastern Europe in the second half of the XIX – early XX centuries: a comparative aspect]. Hileya: naukovyy visnyk. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats’ [Gileya: scientific bulletin. Collection of scientific works], 155, 4, pp. 115-126. [In Ukrainian].

Silin, A.S. (1976). Ekspansiya germanskogo imperializma na Blizhnem Vostoke nakanune pervoj mirovoj vojny. [Expansion of German imperialism in the Middle East on the eve of World War I] Moskva: Nauka. [In Russian].

Wallach Jehuda, L. (1976). Anatomie einer Militarhilfe. Die Preuisch-deutschen Militarmissionen in der Turkei 1835-1919. [Anatomy of a military aid. The Prussian-German military missions in Turkey 1835-1919]. Dusseldorf. [In German].

Uyar, M. (2021). The Ottoman Army and the First World War. Description: Abingdon, Oxon; New York: Routledge. [In English].

Erickson, E.J. (2007). Ottoman Army Effectiveness in World War I: A Comparative Study (Military History and Policy). Praeger Security International. [In English].

Torrey, G. (1998). Romania and World War I: A Collection of Studies. Oxford, Portland: The Center for Romanian Studies. [In English].

Subaev, R.R. (2015). Missiya Limana fon Sandersa i mladotureckij rezhim nakanune Pervoj mirovoj vojny [Mission of Liman von Sanders and the Young Turkish regime on the eve of the First World War]. Slavyanskiy al’manakh [Slavic Almanac], 3-4. [In Russian].

Subbotin, V.A. (2004). Pyat’ let sluzhby v Turtsii: O. Liman fon Sanders [Five years of service in Turkey: O. Liman von Sanders]. Vostok [East], 3, pp. 53-68. [In Russian].

Luneva, Yu.V. (2010). Bosfor i Dardanelly. Tajnye provokacii nakanune Pervoj mirovoj vojny (1908-1914) [Bosphorus and Dardanelles. Secret provocations on the eve of World War I (1908-1914)]. Moskva: Kvadriga; Ob’edinennaya redakciya MVD Rossii. [In Russian].

Hlebnikova, V.B. (2016). Modernizaciya i “evropeizaciya” po-balkanski (k voprosu o prichinah nedolgovechnosti chernogorskoj gosudarstvennosti na rubezhe XIX-XX vv.) [Modernization and “Europeanization” in the Balkan style (on the question of the reasons for the fragility of Montenegrin statehood at the turn of the XIX-XX centuries)] Chelovek na Balkanah. Osobennosti “novoj” yuzhnoslavyanskoj gosudarstvennosti: Bolgariya, Serbiya, Chernogoriya, Korolevstvo SKHS v 1878-1920 gg. Kollektivnaya monografiya [Man in the Balkans. Features of the “new” South Slavic statehood: Bulgaria, Serbia, Montenegro, the Kingdom of the Union of Artists in 1878-1920. Collective monograph.]. (Pp. 261-369). Moskva: Institut slavyanovedeniya RAN. [In Russian].

Kazanova, Yu.V. (2009). Russkaya voenno-instruktorskaya missiya v Makedonii: formirovanie i nachalo raboty (Iz istorii realizacii Myurcshtegskoj programmy) [Russian military instructor mission in Macedonia: formation and start of work (From the history of the implementation of the Mürzsteg program).] Russkij sbornik: Issledovaniya po istorii Rossii. Tom VI. [Russian collection: Studies in the history of Russia. Volume VI]. (Pp. 91-111). Moskva: Modest Kolerov. [In Russian].

Skvoznikov, A.N. (2010). Makedoniya v konce XIX – nachale XX v. – yabloko razdora na Balkanah [Macedonia in the late 19th – early 20th century – the bone of contention in the Balkans.] Samara: Samar. gumanit akad.[In Russian].

Denda, D. (2019). Shlem i shaјkacha: voјni faktor i јugoslovensko-nemachki odnosi (1918-1941) [Helmet and Shajkaca: Military Factor and Yugoslav-German Relations (1918-1941)]. Novi Sad. [In Serbian]

Denda, D. (2021). Serbskaya armiya. 1804-1918. [Serbian army. 1804-1918]. Moskva: Institut slavyanovedeniya RAN. SPb.: Nestor-Istoriya. [In Russian].

Mishev, R. (2018). Epizodi ot istoriyata na evropejskoto i b”lgarsko razuznavane 1878-1918. Balkanski i obshchoevropejski proekcii [Episodes from the history of European and Bulgarian intelligence 1878-1918. Balkan and pan-European projections]. V. T”rnovo: “Ivis” [In Bulgarian].

Κατσικώστας Α. (2014). ∆ηµήτριος “Ν αναδιοργάνωση των ενόπλων δυνάμεων και τοι τργο της γαλλικής στρατιωτικής αποστολής Eydoux” [Katsikostas, A. (2014). Reorganization of the armed forces and the work of the French military mission Eydoux] [Online]. Available from: https://dis.army.gr/sites/dis.army.gr/files/unmanaged/pdf/Articles_June14/Greek_French/ANADIORG_ED_APOST_EYDOUX.pdf [In Greek].

Out, P. (2006). L’influence de la doctrine militaire française sur l’évolution de l’armée roumaine (1878-1940) [The influence of French military doctrine on the development of the Romanian army (1878-1940)] Revue historique des armées [En ligne] 244, mis en ligne le 24 novembre 2008. [Online]. Available from: http://journals.openedition.org/rha/5862 [In French].

Ђukiћ, S. (2019). Strani uticaј na razvoј srpske voјne doktrine u XIX i prvoј deceniјi XX veka [Foreign influence on the development of Serbian military doctrine in the 19th and the first decade of the 20th century]. Beograd: Mediјa centar “Odbrana”. [In Serbian].

Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj voenno-istoricheskij arhiv, g. Moskva [Russian State Military Historical Archive] F. 401 Voenno-uchenyj komitet Glavnogo shtaba Op. 4 D. 43 O komandirovanii instruktorov v Chernogoriyu o naznachenii vospitatelya nasledniku Chernogorskogo prestola, 13.08.1885-30.12.87. [On sending instructors to Montenegro on the appointment of a teacher to the heir to the Montenegrin throne]. [In Russian].

Potapov, N.M. (2003). Russkij voennyj agent v Chernogorii. T. 1. Doneseniya, raporty, telegrammy, pis’ma 1902-1915 [Russian military agent in Montenegro. T. 1. Dispatches, reports, telegrams, letters 1902-1915]. Podgorica-Moskva. [In Russian].

Nikol’skij, E.A. (2007). Zapiski o proshlom [Notes of the Past]. Moskva: Russkij put’. [In Russian].

Puankare, R. (2002). Na sluzhbe Francii 1914-1915 [In the service of France 1914-1915]. Moskva: ACT. [Online]. Available from: http://militera.lib.ru/memo/french/poincare_r/ index.html [In Russian].

Morgentau, G. (2010). Tragediya armyanskogo naroda. Istoriya posla Morgentau [The tragedy of the Armenian people. The story of Ambassador Morgenthau]. Moskva: ZAO Izdatel’stvo Centrpoligraf. [In Russian].

Suhomlinov, V.A. (1926). Vospominaniya Suhomlinova [Memories of Sukhomlinov] Moskva; Leningrad: Gos. izd-vo. [In Russian].

Rediger, A.F. (1999). Istoriya moej zhizni. Vospominaniya voennogo ministra. V dvuh tomah [Story of my life. Memoirs of the Minister of War. In two volumes]. Moskva: Kanon-press; Kuchkovo pole. [Online]. Available from: http://militera.lib.ru/memo/russian/rediger/10.html [In Russian].

Pastuhov, A. (2003). Malye vojny pervoj poloviny XX veka. Balkany [Small wars of the first half of the XX century. Balkans]. Moskva: OOO “Izdatel’stvo ACT”; SPb.: Terra Fantastica. [Online]. Available from: http://militera.lib.ru/h/pastuhov_a/index.html [In Russian].

Sokirkin, D.N. (2015). Deyatel’nost’ britanskih voenno-morskih missij v Grecii i Turcii nakanune pervoj mirovoj vojny [Activities of British naval missions in Greece and Turkey on the eve of World War I. Trudy kafedry istorii novogo i novejshego vremeni [Proceedings of the Department of History of Modern and Contemporary Times]. (Pp. 66-87). Spb.: Sankt-Peterburgskij gosudarstvennyj universitet. [In Russian].

Moro, K. (2015). Germano-tureckij al’yans protiv Rossii nakanune Pervoj mirovoj vojny [German-Turkish alliance against Russia on the eve of World War I]. Score of the Second Patriotic War. Great war 1914-1918 [Partitura Vtoroj Otechestvennoj. Velikaya vojna 1914-1918 gg.]. (Pp. 74-84). Moskva: Veche. [In Russian].

Ruis, E. (2013). Vechtmissie Nederlandse militairen in Albanie 1913-1914. [Combat mission Dutch soldiers in Albania 1913-1914] Just Publishers. [In Netherlands].

Silin, A.S. (1965). Fon der Gol’ts i ego voennaya missiya v Turcii [Von der Goltz and his military mission in Turkey] Germanskij imperializm i militarizm. Sbornik statej [German imperialism and militarism. Digest of articles]. (Pp. 64-91). Moskva: Nauka. [In Russian].

Os’kin, M.V. (2019). Bessarabskij vopros na rubezhe 1917-1918 godov v kontekste russko-rumynskih otnoshenij na izlete Pervoj mirovoj vojny [The Bessarabian question at the turn of 1917-1918 in the context of Russian-Romanian relations at the end of the First World War] Novaya i novejshaya istoriya [New and recent history], 2, pp. 130-145. [Online]. Available from: Available from: https: //nni.jes.su/s013038640008657-0-1/ [In Russian].

Magadeev, I.E. (2017). Vostochnyj front v 1917 godu i perspektivy rossijskoj armii v ocenkah francuzskih voennyh ekspertov [The Eastern Frontin 1917 and the Prospects of the Russian Army in the Estimates of French Military Experts]. Novaya i novejshaya istoriya [New and recent history], 6. [Online]. Available from: https://nni.jes.su/s013038640008657-0-1/ [In Russian].

Kozhuharov, A. (2013). Bolgarskie slushateli artillerijskogo oficerskogo klassa (1901-1914 gody) [Bulgarian students of the artillery officer class (1901-1914)]. Novaya i novejshaya istoriya [New and recent history], 1, pp. 216-220. [In Russian].

Tanchev, I. (2008). B"lgari v chuzhdestranni voennouchebni zavedeniya (1878-1912) [Bulgarians in foreign military schools (1878-1912)]. Sofiya, IK “Gutenberg”. [In Bulgarian].

Vooruzhennye sily Rumynii: (Po dannym k 1 yanv. 1912 g.), (1912). [The Armed Forces of Romania: (As of January 1, 1912)] Sost. Gen. shtaba polk. Iskrickij; Gl. upr. Gen. shtaba. – Sankt-Peterburg: Otd. gen.-kvartirmejstera. [In Russian].

Kashirin, V.B. (2014). Aleksandru Averesku glazami voennoj razvedki Rossijskoj imperii: shtrihi k portretu budushchego marshala Rumynii [To Alexander Averescu through the eyes of the military intelligence of the Russian Empire: touches to the portrait of the future Marshal of Romania]. Slavyanovedenie [Slavic studies], 4, pp. 27-38. [In Russian].

Ter-Oganov, N.K. (2012). Persidskaya kazach’ya brigada. 1879-1921 gg. [Persian Cossack brigade. 1879-1921]. Moskva: Institut vostokovedeniya RAN. [In Russian].

Cronin, S. (1996) An experiment in military modernization: constitutionalism, political reform and the Iranian Gendarmerie, 1910-21. Middle Eastern Studies, 3, (32), pp. 106-138. [In English].

Kaske, E. (2001). Teachers, Drillmasters or Arms Dealers? German Military Instructors in China 1870-1914. 2nd International Convention of Asia Scholars, August 9-12. (Pp. 90-98). Berlin. [In English].

Fischer, F. (2008). La expansión (1885-1918) del modelo military alemán y su pervivencia (1919-1933) en América Latina [The expansion (1885-1918) of the German military model and its survival (1919-1933) in Latin America]. Revista del Cesla, Uniwersytet Warszawski, 11, pp. 135-160. [Online]. Available from: https://www.redalyc.org/pdf/2433/243316550011.pdf [In Spanish].

Kr”steva, M., Sheldon-Dyuble A., Lafarg F., Panajotov A. (2011) Voennomorskite sili na B”lgariya i Franciya v otnosheniyata mezhdu dvete strani (1878-2010 g.). [The Naval Forces of Bulgaria and France in the relations between the two countries (1878-2010)]. Varna: Izdatelstvo Morski svyat. [In Bulgarian].

Koop, G. (2002). Na linejnom krejsere “Geben”. [On the battle cruiser Goeben]. SPb.: Izdanie al’manaha “Korabli i srazheniya”. [In Russian].

Timofeev, A.Yu. & Kremich, D. (eds) (2014). Rossiya na Serbskom fronte Pervoj mirovoj vojny. Pomoshch’ armii i flota Rossii Korolevstvu Serbiya v 19140-1918 gg. (2014). [Russia on the Serbian front of the First World War. Assistance to the Russian army and navy to the Kingdom of Serbia in 1914-1918.]. Moskva: Veche. [In Russian].

Clerc, L. (2009). Entre influence allemande et imbroglio russe: la mission militaire française en Finlande, 1919-1925. [Between German influence and Russian imbroglio: the French military mission in Finland, 1919-1925]. Revue historique desarmées, 254. [Online]. Available from: Available from: http://journals.openedition.org/rha/6403 [In French].

Schramm, T. (1987). Francuskie misje wojskowe w państwach Europy Środkowej 1919-1938. [French military missions in the countries of Central Europe 1919-1938.]. Poznan: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UAM. [In Polish].

Francouzská vojenská mise v Československu 1919-1939. (2008). [French military mission in Czechoslovakia 1919-1939.] Serie I: 1919-1925 Svazek 4. Strategické úvahy, studie, operační plány. Praha [In Czech].

Fal’ko, S.A. (2020). Deyatel’nost’ voenno-instruktorskih missij vedushchih evropejskih stran i Soedinennyh Shtatov Ameriki v mezhvoennyj period (1918-1939 gody) [Activities of military instructor missions of the leading European countries and the United States of America in the interwar period (1918-1939)]. Vchenі zapiski Tavrіjs’kogo nacіonal’nogo unіversitetu іmenі V.І. Vernads’kogo. Serіya: Іstorichnі nauki. [Introductory notes of the Taurian National University to the name of V.I. Vernadsky. Series: Historical Sciences.], 31, (70), 4, pp. 217-226. [In Russian].