Exchange and Repatriation of Disabled and Sick Prisoners of War on the Eastern Front during World War I
Main Article Content
Abstract
The aim of the paper is to study the process of exchange and repatriation of disabled and sick prisoners between the Russian Empire, on the one hand, and the Central States (Austria-Hungary and Germany), on the other hand, during 1914-1918. The research methodology involves the application of general scientific and historical principles and methods of scientific research: analysis and synthesis, problem-chronological, historical, historical-genetic and historical-systemic methods). The scientific novelty consists in addressing the topic, practically unexplored in Ukrainian historiography, as well as in the introduction of a number of sources, which together allow to trace the complex process of exchange and repatriation of sick and maimed prisoners during World War I. Prospects for further research suggest a systematic study of the complex process of exchange of prisoners of war between all participants of the opposing military and political blocs during World War I with the involvement of a wide source base. The conducted scientific exploration allows us to conclude that the process of exchange and repatriation of disabled and sick prisoners of war on the Eastern Front during World War I was rather ad hoc and not properly organised. The criterion for exchange was the state of health of POWs who could be repatriated home or interned in neutral countries, and the selection and medical examination of prisoners had to be carried out by special mixed medical commissions. Despite the agreements worked out and signed between Russia, Austria-Hungary and Germany, the outlined ways of their implementation and the identification of intermediaries to facilitate the implementation of the measures envisaged, the repatriation of prisoners throughout 1915-1918 encountered a number of difficulties, such as: general suspicion and espionage inherent in all the opposing sides; financial, transport and organisational difficulties, etc. Although in the end it yielded rather modest results against the background of the total number of prisoners, the experience gained during World War I laid the foundations for similar practices in subsequent military conflicts.
Downloads
Article Details

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
References
Danylenko, O. (2011). Vijskovopoloneni, internovani j bizhentsi na terytorii ievropejskykh krain iak obiekt dyplomatychnykh vidnosyn (1919-1923 rr.). Mizhnarodni zviazky Ukrainy: naukovi poshuky i znakhidky, 20, рр. 196-213. [Online]. Available from: http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/Mzu_2011_20_16 [In Ukrainian].
Minaieva, T.V. (2016). Repatriatsiia rosijskykh vijskovopolonenykh z Avstro-Uhorschyny ta Nimechchyny pislia Pershoi svitovoï vijny. Istorychna panorama. Spetsial'nist' “Istoriia”, 22-23, рр. 24-52. [In Ukrainian].
Sribniak, I.V. (1999). Poloneni ukraintsi v Avstro-Uhorschyni ta Nimechchyni (1914-1920 rr.). Kyiv: Kyivskyj derzh. linhvist. un-t. [in Ukrainian].
Sribniak, M. (2021). Elektronni arkhivni resursy iak dzherelo vyvchennia protsesu repatriatsii polonenykh ukraintsiv pislia Pershoi svitovoi vijny. Arkhivy Ukrainy, 4, 329 (zhovten'-hruden'), рр. 138-155. [Online]. Available from: https://au.archives.gov.ua/index.php/au/article/view/ 137/101 [In Ukrainian].
Moritz, V., Leidinger, H. (2005). Zwischen Nutzen und Bedrohung. Die russischen Kriegsgefangenen in Österreich (1914-1921). Bonn: Bernard & Graefe Verlag. [In German].
Zhdanov, N. (1920). Russkie voennoplennye v mirovoj vojne 1914-1918 gg. Ch. І, ІІ, ІІІ. / N. Zhdanov; [pod. red. A.A. Svechina i dr.]. Moskva: Voennaya tipografiya Vserosglavshtaba. [In Russian].
Nagornaya, O.S. (2010). “Drugoj voennyj opyt”: rossijskie voennoplennye Pervoj mirovoj vojny v Germanii (1914-1922). Moskva: Novyj khronograf. [In Russian].
Shmihel, M. (2024). Mihratsiia naselennia v Tsentralni ta Skhidnij Yevropi pid chas Velykoi vijny ta u povoiennyj period (1914-1922). Velyka vijna 1914–1918 rr.: osmyslennia trahichnoho dosvidu: kolektyvna monohrafiia / Naukova redaktsiia O.V. Dobrzhans'koho, V.P. Fisanova. Ryha, Latvyia: Izdevnieciba “BaltijaPublishing”, рр. 259-295. [Online]. Available from: http://baltijapublishing.lv/omp/index.php/bp/catalog/view/485/13108/27388-1 [In Ukrainian].
Karelin, V.A. (2010). Problema internirovaniya russkikh voennoplennykh Pervoj mirovoj vojny. Novaya i novejshaya istoriya, 1, рр. 93-105. [In Russian].
Golos iz plena / Po zovu sovesti. Neizvestnaya publicistika V.G. Korolenko 1917-1919 gg. / [vstup. zamet., publ., koment S.N. Dmitrieva]. (1990). Sovetskaya literatura, 11, рр. 103-104. [In Russian].
Gushhin, F.A., Zhebrovskij, S.S. (2010). Plennye generaly Rossijskoj imperatorskoj armii 1914-1917. Moskva: Russkij put. [In Russian].
Bedingungen für den Schwerverwundetenaustausch zwischen Deutschland und Rußland // Anlage 5 zu: Zusammenstellung der Vereinbarungen zwischen Deutschland und den feindlichen Staaten über die beiderseitigen Kriegs- und Zivilgefangenen // Verhandlungen des Reichstag. XIII Legislaturperiode. II Session. Band 320. Anlage zu den Stenografischen Berichten. Nr. 508 bis 708. Von Seite 999 bis 1310. Berlin, 1914/1918. [Online]. Available from: http://daten.digitale-sammlungen.de/~db/bsb00003424/images/index.html?fip=193.174.98.30& seite=664&pdfseitex= [In German].
Popechitelnyj komitet o voennoplennykh kalekakh (1915). Vestnik Krasnogo Kresta, 3, р. 948. [In Russian].
Aleksiievets, M., Orekhovskyj, V. (2011). Diialnist Rosijskoho tovarystva Chervonoho Khresta v orhanizatsii dopomohy vijskovopolonenym u roky Pershoi svitovoi vijny (1914-1918 rr.). Naukovi zapysky Ternopilskoho natsionalnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu imeni Volodymyra Hnatiuka. Seriia: Istoriia, 1, рр. 218-223. [In Ukrainian].
Deyatelnost Komiteta po obmenu i evakuacii voennoplennykh invalidov (1916). Vestnik Krasnogo Kresta, 8, рр. 2789-2790. [In Russian].
Borbotko, P.V., Shmatkov, I.I. (2009). Nekotorye voprosy prakticheskoj realizacii norm mezhdunarodnogo gumanitarnogo prava v gody Pervoj mirovoj vojny. Vestnik Vitebskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. P.M. Masherova, 4 (54), рр. 31-36. [In Russian].
RGIA (Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj istoricheskij arkhiv, g. Sankt-Peterburg). F. 1090. Shingarev Aleksandr Ivanovich. 1894-1918 gg. Op. 1. D. 179. Lisynov K. Russkie voennoplennye v Germanii. Illyustrirovannyj doklad, 1916 g. [In Russian].
DAChO (Derzhavnyj arkhiv Chernivets'koi oblasti). F. 3. Kraevoe upravlenye Bukovyny hor. Chernovtsy. 1854-1918 hh., Op. 1., D. 12867. Tsyrkuliar Voennoho Mynysterstva ob usylenyy kontrolia nad voennoplennymy, 24 noiabria 1917 h. [In Ukrainian].
Shamurin, Yu. (1917). Dva goda v germanskom plenu. Moskva: Obrazovanie. [In Russian].
Pashkov, B. (1917). O Central'nom Komitete. Russkij voennoplennyj, 5, рр. 4-6. [In Russian].
DAChO (Derzhavnyj arkhiv Chernivetskoi oblasti). F. 3. Kraevoe upravlenye Bukovyny hor. Chernovtsy. 1854-1918 hh., Op. 1., D. 12865. Hodovoj otchet o deiatel'nosty spravochnoho biuro po delam voennoplennykh y avstryjskoho komyteta Krasnoho Kresta za 1916 h., 15 marta 1917 h. [In Ukrainian].
Vymin polonenykh ta internovanykh tsyvilnykh osib mizh Avstro-Uhorschynoiu ta Rosiieiu. (1917). Rozsvit. Chasopys polonenykh hromady “Samostijna Ukraina” (Rashtat), 61 (126), р. 4. [In Ukrainian].
RGIA (Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj istoricheskij arkhiv, g. Sankt-Peterburg). F. 1289. Glavnoe Upravlenie pocht i telegrafov MVD. 1877-1917 gg., Op. 13 (Mezhdunarodnaya chast). D. 393. Zhurnaly zasedanij Centralnogo Komiteta po delam o voennoplennykh pri Glavnom Upravlenii Rossijskogo Obshhestva Krasnogo Kresta, 1917 g. [In Russian].
Ukhvaly j bazhannia internatsionalnykh Chervonykh Khrestiv na chetvertyj rik 1917). vijny (Rozsvit Chasopys polonenykh hromady «Samostijna Ukraina» (Rashtat), 62 (127), р. 3. [In Ukrainian].
Kramer, A. (2010). Prisoners in the First World War. Prisoners in War / Ed. by Sibyle Scheipers. New York: Oxford University Press, рр. 75-90. [In English].
Davis, G.H. (1977). Prisoners of War in Twentieth-Century War Economies. Journal of Contemporary History. 12, 4 (Oct.), рр. 623-634. [In English].
Kudrina, Yu.V. (2002). Imperatrica Mariya Fedorovna (1847-1928 gg.). Dnevniki. Pis'ma. Vospominaniya. Moskva: OLMA-PRESS. [In Russian].
Zhurnal № 60 soedinennogo zasedaniya Moskovskogo Gorodskogo Komiteta pomoshhi russkim voennoplennym, Otdelov pomoshhi russkim voennoplennym Vserossijskikh Gorodskogo i Zemskogo Soyuzov, Obedinennoj Organizacii pomoshhi russkim voennoplennym, Moskovskogo Otdeleniya Osobogo Komiteta pomoshhi voennoplennym i Obedinennoj Sanatorno-Kurortnoj Komissii (1917). 21 yanvarya. Moskva. [In Russian].
Tarasevich, A.V. (1917). Otchet po obsledovaniyu lagerej i mest vodvoreniya russkikh voennoplennykh v Avstrii i Vengrii. Moskva: Gorodskaya tipografiya. [In Russian].
Kudrina, Ju. (1998). Das Dänische Rote Kreuz in den Jahren des Ersten Weltkrieges. Zeitgeschichte, 11-12, рр. 375-379. [In German].
Internirovanie v Norvegii (1917). Russkij voennoplennyj, 7, рр. 7-8. [In Russian].
Minaieva, T. (2019). Do pytannia pro vtraty rosijskoi armii vijskovopolonenymy u roky Pershoi svitovoi vijny. Istorychna panorama: Naukovyj zbirnyk ChNU. Spetsialnist “Istoriia”, 28-29, рр. 26-42. [In Ukrainian].
Soglashenie mezhdu Rossiej, s odnoj storony, i Germaniej, Avstro-Vengriej, Bolgariej i Turciej, s drugoj storony, o vozvrashhenii na rodinu ranenykh ili bolnykh voennoplennykh. 25 yanvarya (7 fevralya) 1918 g. (1957). Dokumenty vneshnej politiki SSSR. T. 1. 7 noyabrya 1917 g. – 31 dekabrya 1918 g. Moskva: Gos. izd-vo polit. Literatury, рр. 639-643. [In Russian].
Rossiya i voennoplennye (1917). Russkij voennoplennyj, 5 (oktyabr), рр. 3-4. [In Russian].