The Contribution of the Council on Foreign Relations to Shaping U.S. Foreign Policy Strategy During World War II
Main Article Content
Abstract
The article explores the role of the Council on Foreign Relations in shaping the foreign policy strategy of the United States during World War II. It is demonstrated that the cooperation between the organization and governmental structures laid the foundations for the subsequent institutionalization of the influence of intellectual circles in the process of strategic decision-making in the war years.
The author argues that the American intellectual elite, as a socio-political phenomenon, played a significant role in conceptualizing American foreign policy and national interest. Analyzing the activities of unofficial and semi-official actors, as well as the intellectual networks they created, allows for the reconstruction of a comprehensive picture of intellectual efforts aimed at revising the key directions of U.S. foreign policy during World War II. A prominent role in this process was played by the Council on Foreign Relations, which helped introduce the idea of American global leadership into the official agenda and provided the government with recommendations on how to implement this concept.
An analysis of the documents and official records prepared by the Council on Foreign Relations provides grounds to assert the organization’s ideological influence on the Atlantic Charter of 1941, its subsequent political instrumentalization, and the creation of a new peace platform based on the United Nations format. Equally important is that the Council’s call for the U.S. to lead international processes during the war and in the post-war era was based not only on past historical experience but also on forecasting a confrontation with the Soviet Union. It makes the organization’s research findings especially valuable both for defining foreign policy objectives and for postulating a new vision of the socio-political reality and conditions for national life development as a whole.
Downloads
Article Details

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
References
Parmar, I. (2004). Think Tanks and Power in Foreign Policy. Basingstoke: Palgrave. [In English].
Domhoff, G. W. (1990). The Power Elite and the State: How Policy Is Made in America. London: Routledge. [In English].
Shoup, L. H., Minter, W. (1977). Imperial Brain Trust: The Council on Foreign Relations and United States Foreign Policy. New York and London: Monthly Review Press. [In English].
The War and Peace Studies of the Council on Foreign Relations 1939-1945. (1946). New York: Council on Foreign Relations. [In English].
Parmar, I. (2012). Foundations of the American century: the Ford, Carnegie, and Rockefeller Foundations in the Rise of American Power. Columbia: Columbia University Press. [In English].
Walter M. Mallory to Laurence Duggan. September 11, 1940. Council on Foreign Relations Records: Studies Department Series. Princeton University Library. MC104.3. [In English].
Cordell Hull to Norman H. Davis. November 12, 1940. Council on Foreign Relations Records: Studies Department Series. Princeton University Library. MC104.3. [In English].
Congressional Information Service, Inc. (1987). State Department Records of Harley A. Notter, 1939-1945: Bibliography. Post World War Foreign Policy Planning. [In English].
Atlantic Charter. August 14, 1941. The Avalon Project. Documents in Law, History and Diplomacy. [Online]. Available from: https://avalon.law.yale.edu/wwii/atlantic.asp [In English].
Basic American Interests: Preliminary Draft. Author: Walter R. Sharp. July 10, 1941. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-415-P-B23. [In English].
Notter, H. (1975). Postwar Foreign Policy Preparation, 1939-1945. Connecticut: Greenwood Press. [In English].
Hamilton Fish Armstrong to Sumner Welles. August 7, 1941. Council on Foreign Relations Records: Studies Department Series. Princeton University Library. MC104.3. [In English].
Memorandum of Discussions, Sixteenth Meeting. October 22, 1941. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-16-A-A16. [In English].
American Political Action in the Present Military Crisis. July 3, 1942. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-114-A-B61. [In English].
American Representation in “The United Nations”. Authors: Carter Goodrich, Walter R. Sharp. December 29, 1944. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-483-P-B91. [In English].
The Distinction Between War and International Policing. Author: Payson. June 14, 1943. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-460-P-B68. [In English].
Memorandum of Discussions, Twenty-fourth Meeting. July 1, 1942. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-24-A-A24. [In English].
Subjects: U.S., United Nations. Group: The United States and the United Nations in War and Peace. Program year: 1942/43. December 4, 1942. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. G-71. [In English].
Problems of Postwar International Organization: A Tentative Outline. Authors: Walter R. Sharp, Arthur Sweetser. March 2, 1942. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-429-P-B37. [In English].
Memorandum of Discussions, Thirty-fifth Meeting. May 24, 1943. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-35-A-A35. [In English].
Approaches to Postwar International Organization (preliminary draft). Author: Arthur Sweetser. September 17, 1941. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-422-P-B30. [In English].
American Representation in Critical Areas. Author: Bruce C. Hopper. October 20, 1941. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-574-T-B38. [In English].
War Planning. Authors: Hanson W. Baldwin, George Fielding Eliot, Frank R. McCoy. December 15, 1941. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-88-A-B35. [In English].
An American Commitment on Peace Aims. July 9, 1942. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-436-P-B44. [In English].
National Sovereignty and the International Tasks of the Postwar World. Author: Walter R. Sharp. August 31, 1942. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-440-P-B48. [In English].
American Participation in International Police Activity. Author: Payson S. Wild. Date: June 14, 1943. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-459-P-B67. [In English].
Some Problems of International Policing. Authors: Hanson W. Baldwin, George Fielding Eliot, Grayson Kirk. January 1944. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-702. [In English].
European Regionalism and Postwar World Organization. September 27, 1943. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-463-P-B71. [In English].
Memorandum of Discussions, Fifty-first Meeting. May 15, 1945. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-51-A-A51. [In English].
The Changing Strategic Position of Britain. Author: Hanson W. Baldwin. July 31, 1945. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-176-A-B123. [In English].
The Future of Europe. Author: Count Richard N. Coudenhove-Kalergi. October 22, 1940. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. M-270. [In English].
The United States and the “Colonial Problem”. Author: Jacob Viner. June 24, 1944. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-314-E-B71. [In English].
Dependent Areas in the Postwar World. Author: Walter R. Sharp. August 3, 1942. Microfiche Edition of Records of the Council on Foreign Relations, 1921–1951. Middelburg: Тhe Roosevelt Institute for American Studies. W-437-P-B45. [In English].