Germans of Ukraine in the Interwar Years (1918-1941)

Main Article Content

Alfred Eisfeld

Abstract

The article uses documents covering the process of preparing and conducting by the NKVD bodies of the Ukrainian SSR a massive “German operation” – an integral part of the “Great Terror” in the USSR in 1937-1938. The historical circumstances of the appearance of the order of the NKVD of the USSR No. 00439 of July 25, 1937 and the specifics of its implementation in the Ukrainian SSR are disclosed. They also characterize the methodology for selecting the “contingent” that was repressed (victims of the operation), the technology of conducting mass repressions within the framework of the special operation and their tragic consequences for the German population of Ukraine.


As the operation quickly gained momentum, it was not easy for German diplomats to figure out what was happening in Ukraine. But, as follows from the telegram of the German Embassy to Berlin on August 7, 1937, diplomats saw through the general situation in the USSR. They directly linked the arrests of German citizens “with well-known terrorist acts directed against all sections of the local population”. In other words, they saw and adequately evaluated the German component of what would later be called the “Great Terror” from the first days of the German operation.


The documents that were used confirm that the tragic aspect of the beginning of the operation was the simplification and acceleration of the so-called “German affairs” investigation.


The judiciary, in particular the military tribunals, which were not directly involved in the German operation but were involved in the consideration of cases against people, among whom were Germans – citizens of the USSR, did not lag behind the pace of “work, accused of such serious paragraphs of Article 54 of the Criminal Code of the Ukrainian SSR as treason, espionage, sabotage, terror. The sanction of this article in almost all cases provided for capital punishment – execution, which was widely used in practice. The last point in documenting the repressions against victims of this category was the NKVD bodies reports to the relevant military tribunal about the execution of the sentence of the tribunal.


The prosecution authorities and, to a lesser extent, the USSR People’s Commissariat for Foreign Affairs contributed to the fight against “enemies”. The arrests of some German citizens were coordinated with them.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Eisfeld, A. (2020) “Germans of Ukraine in the Interwar Years (1918-1941)”, Problems of World History, (10), pp. 107–137. doi: 10.46869/2707-6776-2020-10-7.
Section
Articles
Author Biography

Alfred Eisfeld

Eisfeld AlfredPh.D. in History, Executive Director of the Board of the Scientific Society for the Study of the History and Culture of Germans in North-Eastern Europe (Göttingen, Germany), Member of the Federal (All-German) Board of Fellowship of Germans from the CIS.

References

Hrynevych, V.A. & Hrynevych, L.V. (2001) Slidcha sprava M.A. Muravyova: Dokumentovana istoriya [Investigative case MA Muravyova: Documented history]. Kyiv. [In Ukrainian].

Shama, O. (2015) Krasnaya gvardiya. Kak bol’sheviki vpervyye zakhvatili Kiyev i tri nedeli grabili i ubivali mestnykh zhiteley [Red Guard. How the Bolsheviks first captured Kiev and robbed and killed local residents for three weeks]. Novoye vremya [New time], 5, 62-65. [In Russian].

Polozheniye o natsional’nykh sektsiyakh pri partiynykh komitetakh RKP(b) [The regulation on the national sections of the party committees of the RCP (b) (1920)]. Izvestiya TSK RKP(b) [Bulletin of the Central Committee of the RCP (b)], 25, 3. [In Russian].

Sharapov, Ya.Sh. (1967) Natsional’nyye sektsii RKP(b) [National sections of the RCP (b)]. Kazan’: Izd-vo Kazanskogo universiteta. [In Russian].

Aus den deutschen Siedlungen Russlands (1922). Wolgadeutsche Monatshefte. Monatsschrift für Kultur und Wirtschaft der Wolgadeutschen. Berlin, 1 (1. Juli), 89-91. [In German].

Chebotareva, V.G. (2003) Narkomnats RSFSR: Svet i teni natsional‘noy politiki 1917-1924 gg. [People’s Commissariat of the RSFSR: The Light and Shadows of National Politics 1917-1924]. Moskva: Obshchestvennaya akademiya nauk rossiyskikh nemtsev. [In Russian].

Chyrko, B.V. (1995) Natsional’ni menshyny v Ukrayini (20-30 roky XX stolittya) [National minorities in Ukraine (20-30 years of the XX century)]. Kyiv: Asotsiatsiya “Ukrayino”. [In Ukrainian].

Chyrko, B.V. (2015) Nimets’ka natsional’na menshyna v Ukrayini: etnopolitychni ta sotsial’no-ekonomichni protsesy v umovakh radyans’koyi politychnoyi systemy (persha polovyna XX stolittya) [The German national minority in Ukraine: ethnopolitical and socio-economic processes in the Soviet political system (first half of the twentieth century)]. Kyiv: AMU. [In Ukrainian].

Gosudarstvennyy arkhiv Odesskoy oblasti [State archive of Odessa region]. F. P-3. Op. 1. D. 811. [In Russian].

Ostasheva, N.V. (1998) Na perelome epokh... Mennonitskoye soobshchestvo Ukrainy v 1914-1931 gg. [At the turn of the era ... Mennonite community of Ukraine in 1914-1931]. Moskva: Gotika. [In Russian].

Tsirkulyarnoye pis’mo Ob’’yedinennogo gosudarstvennogo politicheskogo upravleniya No 7/37 (po kontrrazvedyvatel’nomu otdelu) [Circular letter of the United State Political Administration No. 7/37 (for counterintelligence department)]. Moskva, 1924. RGASPI. F. 76. Op. 3. D. 317. [In Russian].

Spravka KRO OGPU SSSR “Germanskaya kontrrevolyutsionnaya rabota v SSSR”, iyul’ 1925 g. [Certificate KRO OGPU USSR “German counter-revolutionary work in the USSR”, July 1925]. RGASPI. F. 76. Op. 3. D. 317. [In Russian].

Natsional’naya politika VKP(b) v tsifrakh [National policy of the CPSU (b) in numbers] (1930). Moskva: Izdatel’stvo Kommunisticheskoy Akademii. [In Russian].

Müller, А. (1932) 15 Jahre Oktoberrevolution im deutschen Dorfe. Charkow-Kiew. [In German].

Plesskaya, E.G. (2003) Podgotovka natsional’nykh kadrov dlya nemetskikh shkol Ukrainy (1924-1938 gg.) [Training of national personnel for German schools in Ukraine (1924-1938)]. Nemtsy Odessy i Odesskogo regiona. Sbornik dokladov, sdelannykh na mezhdunarodnykh nauchnykh konferentsiyakh v Gottingene (Germaniya) [Germans of Odessa and Odessa region. Collection of reports made at international scientific conferences in Gottingen (Germany)]. Odessa: Astroprint. [In Russian].

Khaustov, V. (1999) Repressii protiv sovetskikh nemtsev do nachala massovoy operatsii 1937 g. [Repression against Soviet Germans before the mass operation of 1937]. In Shcherbakova, I.L. (ed.) Nakazannyy narod: Repressii protiv rossiyskikh nemtsev. Materialy Mezhdunar. nauch. konf., Moskva, 18-20 noyab. 1998 g. [Punished people: Repression against Russian Germans. Materials Intern. scientific conf., Moscow, November 18-20. 1998]. Moskva. [In Russian].

Yakovlev, A.N. (ed.) (2003) Lubyanka. Stalin i VCHK-GPU-OGPU-NKVD. Arkhiv Stalina. Dokumenty vysshikh organov partiynoy i gosudarstvennoy vlasti. Yanvar’ 1922 – dekabr’ 1936 [Stalin and the Cheka-GPU-OGPU-NKVD. Archive of Stalin. Documents of the highest bodies of party and state power. January 1922 - December 1936]. Moskva: MFD. [In Russian]. https://doi.org/10.1353/kri.2008.0048

Danilova, V., Manning, R. & Viola, L. (eds.) (2001) Tragediya sovetskoy derevni. Kollektivizatsiya i raskulachivaniye. 1927-1939: Dokumenty i materialy: V 5 t. T. 3. Konets 1930-1933 [The tragedy of the Soviet village. Collectivization and dispossession. 1927-1939: Documents and materials: In 5 vol. T. 3. The end of 1930-1933]. Moskva: “Rossiyskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya” (ROSSPEN). [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 16. Op. 1. D. 6. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 13. D. 264. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 13. D. 264. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 13. D. 276. [In Russian].

Chentsov, V.V. (1998) Tragicheskiye sud’by. Politicheskiye repressii protiv nemetskogo naseleniya Ukrainy v 1920-1930-ye gody [Tragic fate. Political repressions against the German population of Ukraine in the 1920-1930s]. Moskva: Gotika. [In Russian].

German, A.A. (2000) Istoriya Respubliki nemtsev Povolzh’ya v sobytiyakh, faktakh, dokumentakh [History of the Volga Germans Republic in events, facts, documents]. Moskva: Gotika. [In Russian].

Mozokhin, O.B. (2006) Pravo na repressii: Vnesudebnyye polnomochiya organov gosudarstvennoy bezopasnosti (1918-1953) [Right to Repression: Extrajudicial Powers of State Security Agencies (1918-1953)]. Moskva: Kuchkovo pole. [In Russian].

Mozokhin, O.B. (2018) Repressii v tsifrakh i dokumentakh. Deyatel’nost’ organov VCHK-OGPU-NKVD-MGB (1918-1953 gg.) [Repression in numbers and documents. The activities of the bodies of the Cheka-OGPU-NKVD-MGB (1918-1953)]. Moskva: Veche. [In Russian]. https://doi.org/10.1353/kri.2008.0048

Korneyev, V.Ye. & Kopylova, O.N. (1992) Arkhivy na sluzhbe totalitarnogo gosudarstva (1918 – nachalo 1940-kh gg.) [Archives in the service of a totalitarian state (1918 – early 1940s)]. Otechestvennyye arkhivy [Domestic archives], 3, 13-24. [In Russian].

Khorkhordina, T.I. (1994) Istoriya Otechestva i arkhivy: 1917-1980 gg. [History of the Fatherland and archives: 1917-1980]. Moskva: RGGU. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 13. D. 111. [In Russian].

TSGAOO Ukrainy. F. 1. Op. 6. D. 396. [In Russian].

Horburov, K. (2015) Z istoriyi ukrayins’ko-pol’s’koho prykordonnya mizhvoyennoyi doby KHKH st.: Markhlevs’kyy pol’s’kyy natsional’nyy rayon USRR 1925-1935 rr. [From the history of the Ukrainian-Polish borderland of the interwar period of the XX century: Markhlev Polish national district of the USSR 1925-1935]. Rehional’na istoriya Ukrayiny [Regional history of Ukraine], 9, 119-140. [In Ukrainian].

Degitayeva, L.D. (ed.) (2000) Postanovleniye SNK SSSR № 776-120 SS “O vyselenii iz USSR i khozyaystvennom ustroystve v Karagandinskoy oblasti Kazakhskoy ASSR 15 000 pol’skikh i nemetskikh khozyaystv” ot 28 aprelya 1936 g. [Decree of the Council of People’s Commissars of the USSR No. 776-120 SS “On the eviction of 15,000 Polish and German households from the Ukrainian SSR and the economic structure in the Karaganda region of the Kazakh Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic” dated April 28, 1936]. Iz istorii polyakov v Kazakhstane (1936-1956 gg.). Sb. dokumentov: Arkhiv Prezidenta Respubliki Kazakhstan [From the History of Poles in Kazakhstan (1936-1956) . Sat documents: Archive of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan]. (pp. 18-21). Almaty: Izd. dom “Kazakhstan”. [In Russian]. https://doi.org/10.20953/1817-7646-2017-1-44-47

AVKH USBU v Khar’kovskoy obl. D. 018769. [In Russian].

Dokladnaya zapiska V. Balitskogo I. Stalinu, aprel’ 1936 g. [Memorandum to V. Balitsky to I. Stalin, April 1936]. OGA SBU. F. 13. D. 408. [In Russian].

Oriyentirovka po delu “Natsional’nyy soyuz nemtsev na Ukraine” [Guidance on the case “National Union of Germans in Ukraine”]. OGA SBU. F. 13 D. 265. [In Russian].

Rublov, A. (ed.) (2016) Delo “Natsional’nogo soyuza nemtsev na Ukraine” 1935-1937 gg.: Dokumenty i materialy [The case of the “National Union of Germans in Ukraine” 1935-1937: Documents and materials]. Kyiv: TOV “Vidavnitstvo “Klío””. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. Uchetno-arkhivnyy otdel KGB pri SM USSR [Accounting and archival department of the KGB at the Council of Ministers of the Ukrainian SSR]. Arkh. No 156. [In Russian].

Zolotarev, V.A. & Stepkin, V.P. (2010) CHK-GPU-NKVD v Donbasse: Lyudi i dokumenty 1919-1941 [ChK-GPU-NKVD in the Donbass: People and documents 1919-1941]. Donetsk: Aleks. [In Russian].

Oriyentirovka po delu likvidirovannoy v Tashkente i Leningrade shpionskoy i diversionnoy rezidentury germanskoy razvedki [Orientation in the case of liquidated in Tashkent and Leningrad espionage and sabotage residency of German intelligence]. OGA SBU. F. Uchetno-arkhivnyy otdel KGB pri SM USSR [Accounting and archival department of the KGB at the Council of Ministers of the Ukrainian SSR]. Arkh. No 267. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 9. D. 7-SP. [In Russian].

Dovbnya, O., Yunhe, M., Binner, R. et al. (eds.) (2010) Velykyy teror v Ukrayini. “Kurkul’s’ka operatsiya” 1937-1938 rr. U 2-kh chastynakh [The Great Terror in Ukraine. “Kurkulsk operation” 1937-1938 pp. In 2 parts]. Ch. I. Kyiv: Vyd. dim “Kyyevo-Mohylyans’ka akademiya”. [In Ukrainian].

OGA SBU. F. 9. D. 36 a. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 16. Op. 1. D. 190. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 16. Op. 30 (1951 g.). D. 31. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 42. D. 32. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 16. Op. 1. D. 120. [In Russian].

(1937) Sobraniye zakonov SSSR [Collection of laws of the USSR], 66, 297. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 16. Op. 1. D. 275. [In Russian].

Petrov, N.V. & Roginskiy, A.B. (1997) “Pol’skaya operatsiya” NKVD 1937-1938 gg. [The ‘Polish operation’ of the NKVD 1937-1938]. In Gur’yanova, A.Ye. (ed.) Repressii protiv polyakov i pol’skikh grazhdan Istoricheskiye sborniki “Memoriala” [Repressions against Poles and Polish citizens. Historical collections of Memorial]. Vyp. 1. Moskva: Zven’ya. [In Russian]. https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230523937_7

Zolotar’ov, V.A. (2004) Oleksandr Uspens’kyy: osoba, chas, otochennya [Oleksandr Uspensky: person, hour, otochennya]. Kharkiv: Folio. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 16. Op. 31 (1951 g.). D. 59. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 42. D. 36 (1938 g.). [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 16. Op. 1. D. 313. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 16. Op. 1. D. 300. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 9. D. 8-SP. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 9. D. 10-SP. [In Russian].

OGA SBU. F. 9. D. 8-SP. [In Russian].

Demydko, V.M., Bezrodnyy, V.P. et al. (eds.) (2004) Reabilitovani istoriyeyu. Donets’ka oblast’ [Rehabilitated by history. Donetsk region]. Kn. 1. Donets’k: Vydavnytstvo KP “Rehion”. [In Ukrainian].

Aysfel’d, A. & Martynenko, V. (2010) Fil’tratsiya i operativnyy uchet etnicheskikh nemtsev Ukrainy organami NKVD-NKGB-MVD-KGB vo vremya Vtoroy mirovoy voyny i v poslevoyennyye gody [Filtration and operational accounting of ethnic Germans of Ukraine by the NKVD-NKGB-MVD-KGB during the Second World War and in the postwar years]. Z arkhívív VUCHK-GPU-NKVD-KGB. Naukoviy í dokumental’niy zhurnal [From the archives of VUCHK-GPU-NKVD-KGB. Scientific and documentary journal], 2, 96-107. [In Ukrainian]. https://doi.org/10.15407/vuchk

Panibud’laska, V.F. (1997) Natsional’ni protsesy v Ukrayini: istoriya i suchasnist’. Dovidnyk. U 2 ch. [National processes in Ukraine: history and modernity. Directory. In 2 vol.]. Ch. 2. Kyiv: Vyshcha shkola. [In Ukrainian].